Douglas Vandergraph

Galatians 5 is one of those chapters that sounds familiar enough to be dangerous. Many people can quote pieces of it. “It is for freedom that Christ has set us free.” “The fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace…” These lines show up on mugs, wall art, social media posts, and sermons so often that we can forget how disruptive they actually are. This chapter is not gentle. It is not trying to soothe anyone who wants to stay comfortable. Galatians 5 is a declaration of independence from every system—religious or cultural—that tries to manage people through fear, guilt, or control. And if we read it honestly, it will unsettle us before it ever comforts us.

Paul is not writing abstract theology here. He is fighting for real people who are being slowly pulled back into spiritual bondage, not by obvious evil, but by something that looks respectable, disciplined, and even holy. The Galatian believers had started with grace. They encountered Christ freely. They experienced transformation without being managed. But then, little by little, voices crept in telling them that freedom was incomplete without rules. That faith needed reinforcement through external markers. That belonging to God required conformity to religious expectations. Paul sees exactly where this road leads, and he does not soften his words.

Galatians 5 begins with a sentence that should stop us in our tracks if we take it seriously. “It is for freedom that Christ has set us free. Stand firm, then, and do not let yourselves be burdened again by a yoke of slavery.” That line assumes something many of us do not like to admit: freedom can be lost. Not stolen by force, but surrendered voluntarily. You can be free in Christ and still choose chains because they feel familiar. You can prefer structure over trust. You can trade relationship for regulation because rules feel safer than reliance on the Spirit.

Paul’s concern is not merely theological correctness. His concern is what happens to the human soul when it begins to measure its worth through performance again. The moment faith becomes a system of maintenance instead of a life of dependence, something breaks. The moment righteousness becomes something you manage instead of something you receive, anxiety returns. Comparison returns. Fear returns. And eventually, control replaces love as the dominant motivator.

What makes Galatians 5 so uncomfortable is that Paul does not aim his warning at obvious legalists alone. He aims it at believers who genuinely want to honor God but are being convinced that grace is insufficient by itself. That is where the danger lives. Rarely does spiritual bondage announce itself as bondage. It presents itself as maturity, discipline, responsibility, or “going deeper.” Paul cuts through that illusion by saying something radical: if you add requirements to Christ, you lose Christ. Not partially. Completely.

He tells them plainly that if they let themselves be circumcised as a requirement for belonging, Christ will be of no value to them at all. That sentence is shocking, and many readers try to soften it. But Paul does not soften it. He means exactly what he says. The issue is not the physical act; it is the spiritual logic behind it. The moment you accept one requirement as necessary for righteousness, you obligate yourself to the entire system. Grace cannot coexist with performance as co-saviors. One will always cancel the other.

This is where Galatians 5 begins to expose our modern equivalents. Most of us are not being pressured into circumcision. But we are constantly being pressured into measurable spirituality. Quiet times that prove devotion. Behavior checklists that signal maturity. Cultural stances that mark belonging. Language cues that identify insiders. Political alignments that masquerade as righteousness. None of these things are inherently evil, but the moment they become conditions for acceptance, the gospel is no longer the gospel.

Paul’s language becomes even sharper when he says that those who are trying to be justified by the law have been alienated from Christ and have fallen away from grace. That phrase, “fallen away from grace,” is often misunderstood. Paul is not saying they committed a moral failure. He is saying they changed operating systems. They moved from grace as their foundation to self-effort as their framework. Grace did not leave them; they left grace.

This is where Galatians 5 becomes deeply personal. Many believers do not reject grace outright. They simply treat it as an entry point instead of a way of life. Grace gets you saved, but effort keeps you acceptable. Grace forgives, but discipline earns favor. Grace covers the past, but rules secure the future. Paul dismantles that entire structure. He insists that the same grace that saved you is the grace that sustains you, shapes you, and produces fruit in you.

And that leads to one of the most misunderstood tensions in this chapter: freedom versus self-indulgence. Paul knows exactly how his message could be twisted. If there is no law keeping us in line, then what stops chaos? If righteousness is not enforced externally, then what prevents moral collapse? Paul answers this not with new rules, but with a deeper trust in transformation. He says that freedom is not an invitation to gratify the flesh, but an invitation to serve one another humbly in love.

That line reveals something profound. True freedom does not remove responsibility; it relocates it. Instead of being controlled by external commands, the believer is now guided by love. Instead of asking, “What is allowed?” the question becomes, “What builds others up?” Love becomes the governing force, not fear of punishment or desire for reward.

Paul summarizes the entire law with one command: love your neighbor as yourself. This is not a downgrade from complexity to simplicity. It is a move from surface obedience to internal transformation. Rules can regulate behavior, but love reshapes motivation. And that is why Paul warns that when communities abandon love, they inevitably turn on each other. “If you bite and devour each other,” he says, “watch out or you will be destroyed by each other.” Legalism always produces hostility because it thrives on comparison. Someone must always be doing better or worse for the system to function.

Then Paul introduces the concept that anchors the rest of the chapter: walking by the Spirit. This is not mystical language meant to confuse. It is relational language meant to liberate. Walking implies movement, attentiveness, and trust. You do not walk by memorizing rules. You walk by responding to presence. The Spirit is not a checklist; the Spirit is a guide.

Paul describes an internal conflict that every honest believer recognizes. The flesh desires what is contrary to the Spirit, and the Spirit desires what is contrary to the flesh. This is not an excuse for failure; it is an explanation of tension. Christianity does not eliminate struggle. It redefines the battlefield. The struggle is no longer about earning acceptance but about choosing which voice to follow.

What matters here is Paul’s conclusion: if you are led by the Spirit, you are not under the law. That does not mean moral anarchy. It means a different source of authority. The law tells you what to do from the outside. The Spirit transforms your desires from the inside. One restrains behavior; the other renews the heart.

Paul then lists the acts of the flesh, and many readers focus on this section as if it is the main point. It is not. The list is descriptive, not prescriptive. Paul is not handing down a new law code. He is showing what happens when desire is disconnected from love and guided by self. The list spans obvious moral failures and socially acceptable sins alike. Sexual immorality sits next to jealousy. Drunkenness appears alongside selfish ambition. This alone dismantles our habit of ranking sins to protect our image.

What is striking is Paul’s warning that those who live like this will not inherit the kingdom of God. He is not talking about isolated failures or moments of weakness. He is talking about a way of life that resists transformation. A life consistently oriented around self rather than love is incompatible with the kingdom because the kingdom itself is built on self-giving love.

But Paul does not leave us in warning. He moves us toward hope. And that hope arrives not as a command but as fruit.

The fruit of the Spirit is not something you manufacture. Fruit grows when conditions are right. You do not strain to produce fruit; you remain connected to the source. Love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control are not personality traits reserved for a few. They are evidence of a life rooted in the Spirit.

This is where many believers feel tension. We read this list and immediately start evaluating ourselves. How loving am I? How patient was I this week? Do I have enough self-control? But Paul never intended this list to become another measuring stick. Fruit is not a performance metric. It is a sign of life. The question is not, “Am I producing enough?” The question is, “What am I rooted in?”

Paul ends this section by saying that against such things there is no law. That line is easy to overlook, but it is powerful. Where the Spirit is producing fruit, rules become unnecessary. You do not need a law to command kindness when kindness flows naturally. You do not need a regulation against envy when contentment has taken root.

Those who belong to Christ, Paul says, have crucified the flesh with its passions and desires. This does not mean desire disappears. It means desire is no longer in control. The old self that demanded satisfaction at any cost has lost its authority. A new life has begun, not one driven by repression, but one guided by transformation.

Paul’s final exhortation in this chapter is simple and demanding: since we live by the Spirit, let us keep in step with the Spirit. That phrase suggests alignment, not anxiety. You can be alive in the Spirit and still walk out of rhythm. Keeping in step requires attention, humility, and responsiveness. It requires letting go of comparison and competition, which Paul names explicitly. Conceit, provocation, and envy are signs that we have slipped back into performance mode.

Galatians 5 leaves us with a choice that feels both freeing and frightening. We can live managed lives, where righteousness is measured, enforced, and displayed. Or we can live led lives, where righteousness is formed quietly, deeply, and relationally. One offers control. The other requires trust.

This chapter is not calling us to try harder. It is calling us to surrender deeper. Not to abandon holiness, but to stop outsourcing holiness to systems that cannot produce life. Freedom in Christ is not the absence of direction. It is the presence of the Spirit.

And that raises a question we cannot avoid: are we willing to live unprotected by rules if it means being fully dependent on grace?

Galatians 5 does not end with fireworks or flourish. It ends quietly, almost dangerously quietly, with a call to alignment. “Since we live by the Spirit, let us keep in step with the Spirit.” That sentence sounds gentle, but it dismantles an entire way of approaching faith. It assumes that the Christian life is not primarily about achieving milestones or maintaining appearances, but about learning to listen, adjust, and respond in real time. It assumes that God is present, active, and communicative, not distant and procedural. And for many believers, that assumption is more unsettling than any list of commands.

Because rules create distance. They give us space to hide. If righteousness is defined externally, then obedience can be mechanical. You can comply without being transformed. You can perform without being known. Walking by the Spirit removes that buffer. It means God is not merely evaluating outcomes; He is shaping desires. It means the work of holiness happens in places no one else sees—intentions, reactions, impulses, internal narratives. And that level of intimacy cannot be managed through religious systems alone.

This is why Galatians 5 is not a chapter about moral improvement. It is a chapter about identity. Paul is not trying to produce better-behaved people. He is fighting to preserve a way of life where identity flows from relationship, not regulation. Everything in this chapter hinges on who defines you. If your identity is anchored in Christ, then freedom makes sense. If your identity is anchored in performance, then freedom feels reckless.

Paul understands that humans are drawn to systems because systems feel secure. They offer predictability. They tell you where you stand. They provide measurable progress. But they also subtly replace trust with transaction. If I do this, then I am accepted. If I avoid that, then I belong. Over time, the heart learns to negotiate with God instead of resting in Him.

Galatians 5 exposes how fragile that arrangement is. Because the moment you fail—and everyone eventually does—the system turns on you. Shame enters. Fear returns. And instead of running toward grace, people either double down on effort or quietly withdraw. Neither response produces life. Paul knows this. That is why he insists that freedom is not optional in the gospel. It is essential.

One of the most overlooked aspects of Galatians 5 is how communal it is. This chapter is not written to isolated individuals trying to be spiritually impressive. It is written to a community being torn apart by competing definitions of righteousness. When freedom is replaced with performance, comparison becomes inevitable. People begin to measure themselves against one another. Spiritual pride grows. Judgment hardens. And love erodes.

Paul’s warning about biting and devouring one another is not hyperbole. Communities built on performance always fracture. Someone will always feel superior, and someone will always feel excluded. But communities rooted in the Spirit grow differently. Fruit is not compared; it is shared. Love does not compete. Joy does not diminish when others experience it. Peace is not threatened by difference.

This is where the fruit of the Spirit becomes more than a personal checklist. It becomes a communal vision. Imagine a community where love governs disagreement, where patience shapes conversations, where gentleness is not mistaken for weakness, and where self-control restrains ego rather than desire alone. That kind of community cannot be engineered. It cannot be mandated. It can only be cultivated through shared dependence on the Spirit.

Paul’s emphasis on crucifying the flesh is often misunderstood as harsh self-denial. But in the context of Galatians 5, it is not about suppressing humanity; it is about dethroning it. The flesh Paul describes is not the body itself but the self-centered orientation that insists on control. Crucifying the flesh means releasing the need to be right, to be superior, to be validated through comparison. It means letting go of the false self that thrives on applause and certainty.

What replaces it is not emptiness, but life. “Since we live by the Spirit…” Paul does not say “since we are trying to live” or “since we hope to live.” He states it as a present reality. Life has already been given. The question is whether we will live in alignment with that life or resist it by clinging to familiar patterns.

Keeping in step with the Spirit implies attentiveness. It implies humility. You cannot keep in step if you are always rushing ahead to prove something or lagging behind out of fear. You keep in step by paying attention. By noticing when love is being replaced with irritation. By recognizing when freedom is being traded for control. By listening when the Spirit nudges you toward generosity, restraint, courage, or compassion.

This kind of life does not photograph well. It does not always look impressive. It often looks ordinary. But it is deeply transformative. Over time, fruit grows. Not because you are striving to be spiritual, but because you are remaining connected to the source of life.

Galatians 5 ultimately asks us to trust something deeper than our ability to manage ourselves. It asks us to trust that God is capable of producing righteousness in us through relationship rather than regulation. That the Spirit can do what rules never could. That freedom, rightly understood, does not lead away from holiness but straight into it.

The tragedy Paul is trying to prevent is not moral failure. It is spiritual amnesia. Forgetting how you began. Forgetting who set you free. Forgetting that grace was never meant to be replaced, only lived out. The moment faith becomes about maintaining status instead of abiding in love, the gospel has been reduced to a system it was meant to dismantle.

Galatians 5 does not give us more to do. It gives us more to trust. It invites us to stop asking whether we are allowed and start asking whether we are aligned. It calls us away from fear-based obedience and toward love-shaped freedom. And it reminds us that the Christian life is not about proving anything to God, but about walking with Him.

Freedom does not need permission. It only needs courage.

Your friend,
Douglas Vandergraph

Watch Douglas Vandergraph’s inspiring faith-based videos on YouTube.

Support the ministry by buying Douglas a coffee.